I've eaten pizza all over the world, and one thing I've learned is that great pizza comes in all shapes, sizes and price ranges.
I've enjoyed everything from inexpensive neighborhood slices to pizzas made by some of the best-known shops around. New York, New Haven, Chicago, Naples. Different styles, different traditions, and plenty of opinions about what makes a great pizza.
I love them all.
So when Rupiani's Pizza offered to send me three of their frozen Chicago deep-dish pizzas to try, I was interested. Especially when I saw the price.
Three pizzas for $165, delivered. That's $55 per pizza.
Not exactly your typical frozen pizza.
But after baking, slicing and tasting Rupiani's, I can tell you this: It's an excellent pizza.
Let's Talk About the Pizza
Chicago deep dish is a different experience from a traditional thin-crust pizza. It's substantial, with a thick base, plenty of cheese and a generous amount of sauce.
With that much going on, balance becomes especially important.
And that's one of the things I enjoyed about Rupiani's.
The Sauce
The sauce really impressed me.
It's a cooked, tomato-forward sauce with relatively light seasoning. The tomato flavor comes through without being overwhelmed by herbs or spices.
What I particularly enjoyed was how well the sauce held up against the other ingredients.
With a thick crust and a substantial amount of cheese, a weak sauce can easily get lost. That doesn't happen here.
There's enough depth and richness to keep the tomato flavor present in every bite.
The Crust
The crust is thick and substantial, exactly what you'd expect from this style of pizza.
It develops a nice crunch on the outside while providing a solid base for all that cheese and sauce.
This is a pizza that needs to be baked thoroughly. With so much filling, getting the center properly heated is important, so pay attention to the cooking process.
When prepared properly, the crust provides a satisfying contrast to the softer cheese and sauce.
The Cheese
There's plenty of it, and it's excellent.
The cheese has a rich flavor and works beautifully with the sauce. Despite the generous amount, I didn't find that it overwhelmed the pizza.
That's another area where the balance works.
You get the richness of the cheese, the tomato flavor from the sauce and the texture of the crust in each bite.
Now Let's Talk About the Price
Here's where my financial planning background comes into play.
I've spent more than 30 years as a Certified Financial Planner, and I've also studied culinary arts. So I tend to look at food from two perspectives: quality and value.
And they're not necessarily the same thing.
I've eaten five-dollar pizzas that were absolutely fantastic. I've also enjoyed thousand-dollar meals at Michelin-starred restaurants.
A high price doesn't guarantee great food, and inexpensive doesn't mean inferior.
Rupiani's costs $165 for three pizzas, including delivery.
Each pizza weighs approximately 2½ pounds, which works out to about $22 per pound, including shipping.
That's certainly expensive compared with a typical frozen pizza at the grocery store.
But when comparing Rupiani's with other premium frozen pizzas shipped nationwide, the price per pound can actually be lower.
Of course, weight isn't everything. You're not buying pizza by the pound alone. You're buying flavor, quality, convenience and the overall experience.
And in those areas, I think Rupiani's delivers.
Is Rupiani's Worth It?
For me, the answer is yes.
Would I order it every Friday night? Probably not. At $55 per pizza, it's more of a specialty purchase.
But if you love Chicago deep dish, want to experience something different, or are looking for a substantial pizza delivered to your door, Rupiani's is definitely worth considering.
The sauce is flavorful without being overly seasoned. The crust is substantial with a nice crunch. The cheese is excellent, and the overall balance makes this a very enjoyable pizza.
Is it expensive? Yes. Is it excellent? Also yes.
And sometimes, a premium product actually delivers a premium experience.
Rupiani's is one I'd happily recommend.
My Final Thoughts
I've always believed that food brings people together. Whether it's a five-dollar slice shared with friends or an elaborate dinner at a Michelin-starred restaurant, the best food experiences aren't always determined by the price tag.
Rupiani's makes an excellent Chicago deep-dish pizza. It's substantial, flavorful and thoughtfully put together.
And yes, I'd spend my own money to enjoy it again.
Disclosure: Rupiani's provided three pizzas at no charge for this review. The opinions expressed here are entirely my own.
Dough Daddy Cooks — Bringing people together, one bite at a time.
Use discount code DOUGHDADDY15 for $15 off