Hartford Pizza Garden - Hartford, CT

Jul 2

June 12, 2026

The Slice Mob rolled into Hartford Pizza Garden’s new location today, and we were not disappointed.

First things first, plenty of parking. That’s already a win in Hartford.

Walking inside, the vibe is cool, relaxed, and full of pizza nostalgia. There are nods to Hartford pizza history throughout the space, but what really catches your eye are the hydroponic gardens suspended above the dining room. Fresh basil is growing right over your head and eventually finds its way onto the pizzas. That’s a pretty neat touch.

The best way I can describe Hartford Pizza Garden is this: it’s like the Town Green in Pizza Heaven.

They’ve got New Haven-style, Grandma, and Detroit pizza all under one roof.

I started with the New Haven red pie. Nice crunch, plenty of flavor, and a beautiful bake underneath. The sauce is bright, bold, and tomato-forward with Parmigiano and fresh basil added after the bake. The sauce isn’t over-seasoned, allowing the tomatoes to take center stage and do what they do best.

Next up was the Grandma pie.

Thicker than the New Haven pie and built upside-down style. The sauce and cheese complement each other perfectly. The crust was soft and pillowy with a crunchy underside that kept me reaching for another slice.

Then came the Detroit.

The thickest of the three with a beautiful open crumb. Soft, tender, and sturdy enough to support all the toppings. Same excellent sauce, loaded with cup-and-char pepperoni. The crispy pepperoni adds great texture against the soft base. And that frico along the edge? Yes please. The fried cheese crust paired perfectly with the pepperoni and added another layer of crunch and flavor.

A couple of other customer favorites are the Taco Pizza and the Shepherd’s Pie Pizza. Unfortunately, I ran out of room before I could tackle those. There are limits to my talent.

If you’re looking for a spot that offers three distinct pizza styles, a fun atmosphere, and some serious attention to detail, Hartford Pizza Garden is worth a visit.

The Slice Mob will definitely be back.